Est. in Defiance, Ohio
Small-batch ice cream made from real ingredients, served with warmth on Evansport Road. Every scoop tells a story.
Our Selection
Every batch is handcrafted in small quantities using locally sourced dairy and the finest natural ingredients. No artificial colors, no shortcuts.
Our namesake blend — vanilla bean, a hint of pea flower, and a whisper of honey. Light, floral, unforgettable.
Single-origin cacao, rich and velvety with a bittersweet finish. For those who like their chocolate honest and unapologetic.
Local wildflower honey swirled into creamy oat milk base. Dairy-free, deeply comforting, and quietly luxurious.
Fresh strawberries from nearby farms, folded into a bright, tangy cream. A taste of Ohio summer in every spoonful.
Vermont-grade maple syrup meets locally roasted walnuts. Earthy, sweet, and satisfyingly crunchy throughout.
Our rotating selection changes with the seasons — always something new to discover. Ask about today's special.
Flavors subject to seasonal availability · All ingredients sourced from local Ohio farms when possible
Our Story
Sweet Pea's was born from a simple belief: that the best ice cream doesn't need a big city to exist. On a quiet stretch of Evansport Road in Defiance, we set out to make something genuine — ice cream that tastes like it was made by someone who actually cares.
Every batch starts with real cream, farm-fresh eggs, and ingredients we can pronounce. We churn in small quantities so every flavor is at its peak when you taste it. Some days you'll find our classics. Other days, something unexpected — because that's how we keep things interesting.
Flavors at a time
Real ingredients
Ohio sourced
Our Philosophy
"The best things in Defiance aren't loud — they're made slowly, with attention, and shared generously."
Every batch is made fresh each morning. We'd rather sell out than serve yesterday's work.
We partner with Ohio farmers for our dairy, fruit, and seasonal ingredients. Your scoop supports our community.
No artificial colors, no preservatives, no shortcuts. Just honest ingredients and a whole lot of patience.
Visit Us
We're right here on Evansport Road, easy to find and even easier to welcome. Pull up, pick a flavor, and stay a while.
Address
1582 Evansport Rd
Defiance, OH 43512
Hours
Hours may vary on holidays — call ahead to confirm.
Phone
(419) 428-2388Get in Touch
Whether you have a question about our flavors, want to plan a visit, or just want to say hi — drop us a line. We read every message.
Thank you!
We'll get back to you as soon as we can. In the meantime, stop by the shop — we'd love to meet you.
